Not Your Grandma’s Cupcakes began with a simple belief: desserts should be fun, bold, and full of personality — just like the people we bake them for.

Founded and owned by Sheila Hulsman, our bakery quickly became a sweet staple in Broken Arrow, where our storefront welcomed families, friends, and cupcake lovers for several wonderful years.

While we no longer operate a physical shop, our ovens are still warm and our creativity is still in full swing. Today, we continue serving the community we love by offering custom cakes, cupcakes, and specialty treats made with the same heart, flavor, and attention to detail that built our reputation.

From birthday celebrations to fundraisers, from simple cravings to once‑in‑a‑lifetime moments, we’ve always believed in helping bring tasty dreams to life. Every order is personal to us and offers a chance to be part of your story, your celebration, and your memory.

Not Your Grandma’s Cupcakes isn’t just a bakery. It’s a community tradition, a creative outlet, and a place where flavor and imagination meet. And with Sheila at the helm, we’re excited to keep baking joy for years to come.